Economist: recession to benefit hog producers?

25-11-2008 | |

It does not seem possible, but the current recession may help hog producers by lowering feed costs, writes Chris Hurt. Lower costs in combination with smaller pork supplies in 2009 could be the combination that puts the industry back into profitability.

Hog prices may actually increase a few dollars in 2009 as the pork industry in both the US and Canada reduce breeding herds due to this year’s losses. However, many uncertainties continue for the pork industry.

Hog price collapse
Most recently, hog prices collapsed along with all other farm commodities. From a high of $62.56 average in August, live hog prices are expected to average about $39 for November. The last time prices dropped this much from their summer highs was in 1998 when prices dropped by more than $25 per live hundredweight.
Surprisingly, most of the decline is attributable to demand factors. Pork exports were flying high this past spring and summer as a result of a weak US dollar and aggressive buying by China prior to hosting the August Olympics. In the period from April through July, exports represented 24 percent of US production compared to 13 percent for the same period in 2007.
Since last summer, several events have reduced pork trade. After the Olympics, China greatly reduced their purchases from the US In the first-half of 2008, China accounted for 50 percent of the growth in US pork exports. Their peak activity came in the second quarter when Chinese purchases reached about seven percent of all US production. Chinese purchases then collapsed in the third quarter, dropping by more than 60 percent to about 2.5 percent of US production.
US dollar
Secondly, the exchange rate of the US dollar has increased about 20 percent since July lows, making pork more expensive for foreign buyers. This has resulted in USDA’s export projections being lowered by seven percent for 2008 and by a more robust 12 percent for all of 2009.
The financial crisis has had severe impacts on hog prices as well. Since September 26th when the crisis began to unfold, December lean hog futures have fallen by about $9 per carcass hundredweight, or about 14 percent. The impact on meat consumption is related to concerns about the depth of the recession.
Generally, the negative impacts are greater for beef than for pork. Pork is generally a lower cost retail product relative to beef and is somewhat favoured when consumers become more value conscious. Retail pork prices so far this year have averaged $2.92 per pound compared to $4.31 for retail beef.
Drop expected
What does all this mean for hog prices and producer incomes in the coming year? Pork production is expected to drop by two to three percent in 2009. This may help hog prices average a few dollars per hundredweight higher than the $48 live price in 2008.
Somewhat higher hog prices will be welcomed by producers, but even more important may be lower feed prices. Estimated costs of production in 2008 were near $53, but current localized futures prices suggest costs could drop into the $46 to $48 range for 2009.  Current forecasts are for cash corn to average about $3.50 in the coming year compared to about $4.60 a bushel this year. Soybean meal is currently about $260 (Decatur) for 2009 compared to an estimated $330 for this year.
Farrow-to-finish pork producers operated under losses for much of 2008, averaging about $5 per live hundredweight, or about $14 per hog. For 2009, current price relationship could return the industry to about $5 per hundredweight of profits as prices move from the mid-to-upper $40s in the first quarter to the lower-to-mid $50s in the second and third quarters and finish the year in the very high $40s.
Recession’s impact
However uncertainties will abound, including the extent of the recession’s impact on domestic consumption and trade. In addition, feed prices, while more moderate now, will remain a key to a profitable 2009. Opportunities to both hedge lower feed prices and profitable lean hog futures prices for 2009 are now available. All producers will welcome these improved prospects, and high risk producers will especially want to consider taking some of these positive margins.

Source: Chris Hurt, Extension Economist, Purdue University

Click here for the free Pig Progress newsletter